Saturday, September 18, 2010

What, me worry?


I woke up in the early hours of the morning and couldn't get back to sleep. So, I lay there and wondered what was that low flying plane doing at night over our peaceful city? That thought entertained me for a short while, and then Ian woke up and padded into the bathroom and back to bed. Instead of playing possum like I normally do so I can get some decent sleep, we talked. And what did we talk about? Chris? No. Taylor or Alex? No. We talked about Ian having his mercury fillings extracted and I warned him that doing it quickly can lead to psychological trauma and he could go insane! We laughed. Insanity has no hold on us any longer. I know of someone who claimed that her daughter having all her fillings replaced at once led to years of pychosis. I also know someone who claimed that having them all removed quickly cleared up his physical and mental health. Go figure.

I am so grateful that waking up in the middle of the night these days does not lead to constant worry like it used to. Ian and I have passed our one year anniversary of not discussing Chris with each other. We made this pact when Chris left the psych hospital after his relapse. In the past, Chris's peculiarities and our dealing with the doctors drove us mad with worry and we would confide our worries to each other. This invariably led to strife because we each had a different idea about how to handle this.  We no longer seem very interested in what Chris is doing. We have taken the long term view, that if we just leave him alone and provide whatever professional support we can, then he will get better. He certainly seems like he's getting better, but we are no longer there to take his pulse.

This is our own version of practicing low expressed emotion. It means not discussing Chris. This strategy has miraculously allowed us to stop worrying. We trust that all will be well.

Thursday, September 16, 2010

The wounded warrior

This post is a tribute to Gianna Kali, the creator of Beyond Meds, a blog about withdrawal from medications, but not just a blog about withdrawal. Gianna has chosen to continue her healing journey without the tiring demands of daily blogging. Gianna Kali is her pseudonym. Perhaps she took inspiration from the Hindu goddess Kali, the dark goddess, whose name is associated with time and change.



Like most goddesses, Kali is controversial. Her goddess persona changes with the time. She has an original terrible side associated with death and destruction, but also a later repositioning as a warm and kind maternal Mother of the Universe. Like a mother, she is a protectress of last resort. Indian mythology is complex and has evolved over thousands of years. Since I am not an Indian scholar, I will leave interpretation to others, such as this writer:

Of all the forms of Devi, She is the most compassionate because She provides moksha or liberation to Her children. She is the counterpart of Shiva the destroyer. They are the destroyers of unreality. Of all the forms of Devi, She is the most compassionate because She provides moksha  person who is attached to his or her ego will not be receptive to Mother Kali and she will appear in a fearsome form. A mature soul who engages in spiritual practice to remove the illusion of the ego sees Mother Kali as very sweet, affectionate, and overflowing with incomprehensible love for Her children.

Gianna Kali is generous of spirit. She chronicles her healing journey to help others and she has helped neophyte bloggers like me spread our message through her blog. Spiritual to begin with, she eventually found herself on the painful path she was destined to take.

In the book, Goddess Shift: Women Leading for a Change, Dr. Susan Kolb writes about her own healing journey in terms of the mythology of the wounded warrior. In order to heal others, a person has to undergo a revolutionary healing journey of her own. This is a sacred journey, also documented as the path of the alchemist. The warrior emerges stronger, wiser, better able to carry on and an inspiration to others. Through ordeal, the warrior comes to know herself.

Thank you Gianna and all good wishes for your continuing recovery. We look forward to hearing from you when you are ready.

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Shapes and angles

I was rummaging through my purse cleaning out debris from my recent vacation and I came across an article that I had torn from USA Today, Transitioning to college with a learning disability. According to the article the number of programs offered to students with learning disabilities at the nation's colleges have skyrocketed since 2001 from 22 to more than 250.  I get interested when I read these things in a "follow the money" curiousity. With programs come employment opportunities. Through grant money, the Department of Education encourages post-secondary institutions to establish transition programs for students with learning disabilities who want to go to college. According to the article, the number is "only going to increase"

Fair enough, I suppose for people with certain well documented learning disabilities like dyslexia, but then we come to a learning disability cited in the article that has to do with an "inability to recognize shapes and angles." The girl cited in the article has been receiving help for this since grade 3. My thinking is that maybe she should not major in math or design. When my sons were at school, so many children had very specific learning disabilities that sounded similar to the shapes and angles one, or else they involved "auditory processing deficits" or not being able to find the right word to use. They received extra time on tests. Is this proliferation of really specific learning disabilities that most people will eventually manage to compensate for, really all that necessary? I guess so, since there's a huge help industry out there that is "only going to increase."

Monday, September 13, 2010

Mere alcohol doesn't thrill me at all


Chris is quite perky these days. There are very few times in his life where I have seen him thrilled, but Sunday was one of them. His friend from high school who used to be in a band with him, phoned him out of the blue and asked if he would join his new classic rock band. No hesitation in saying "yes."

The other times in his life where I would say he was thrilled are the following: Getting his first guitar, getting a laptop, our buying a la-z-boy recliner for our living room (all the men in the house were thrilled!) and being in a band.

He knows he has bigger things to think about, like a career direction, and he is working on these, slowly, while getting lots of support from others. For now, he is thrilled and it sure suits him.

Early separation trauma

The hardest thing for me about Dr. Clancy Mackenzie's theory of early separation trauma for schizophrenia is in reviewing the way we lived our life when Chris was a baby. According to Dr. Mackenzie, he can tell from the way the person expresses pychosis, the age at which the separation trauma occurred. He links it invariably to separation from the mother, not the "mothering one."

Here's what Chris's early life was like from a separation point of view. When Chris was four months of age, I went back to work and we employed a woman to come into our apartment and take care of him while Ian and I were at work. We felt this arrangement was preferable to day care for us. After less than a year, "Gloria" was no longer able to continue and we employed her mother. When Chris was two and half years old, Alex was born and we moved to a house in the suburbs. We felt that Gloria's mother was too old to make the commute every day and we found a young live-in nanny. We employed a succession of live-in nannies until our youngest, Taylor, was in kindergarten.

Dr. Mackenzie would have a field day with the situation and the many caregivers. We honestly felt that   keeping Chris at home and not taking him out to daycare was the least disruptive option.

Dr. Mackenzie claims that he can pinpoint from observing someone by their behaviour, reality and feelings the age at which the trauma occurred. He relates how a woman came into his office and said she had schizophrenia for the past twelve years, and he said "no you don't. You have schizoaffective disorder." He believes that schizophrenia has its origins in the first eighteen months of life and he told her that her trauma happened at 20 months. (Her younger brother was born when she was 20 months old.) This was obvious to him because he felt she had too much warmth and affect for a person traumatized before twenty months. (While Dr. Mackenzie's schizoaffective/schizophrenia distinction is disturbing to people like me who don't care for labelling, I think I get where he is coming from.)

Dr. Mackenzie's trauma theory is compelling because he claims that the trauma is specifically within the first eighteen months and that it is separation anxiety. A quick reading of his website shows that he believes that the best expressed emotion is not low expressed emotion but zero expressed emotion, which means that the traumatized person has to break off all ties with the family while healing takes place. This sounds promising in that it has worked for other people, but how is this achieved in practice? We tried to encourage Chris to leave (for his own good!) two years ago and we got relapse in return. Where does someone go when they have no money or job skills?

Dr. Mackenzie may not have it all right, but he has made a good enough case to investigate further, which I will do when I am brave enough to follow up. Kris at Borderline Families is also getting the ball rolling on her blog post.

Friday, September 10, 2010

The child's world is small

A recent comment from Anonymous sent me scurrying to Bruce E. Levine's Huffington Post article Thinking Critically About Scientology, Psychiatry and their Feud.

Interesting article, but what really got me thinking was the author's commonly enough held opinion that mental illness is a rational response to an insane world, which I am now re-examining. (The schizophrenia diagnosis has made me get around eventually to re-examining everything. It's been a blessing.)

It was R.D. Laing, who made the original insane world observation and people like me have been making this argument ever since. Except that I am more of the opinion now that mental illness is the direct result of not the larger world (society) that most people have in mind, but the smaller world - the child's world - the familiar environment, the family, not some abstract thing called "society." People don't go insane because there is air pollution or poverty in the world. Their suppressed sense of self has made them sensitive to these problems, yes, but people are more likely to go insane because the family environment is polluted with lies or has a poverty of emotional warmth or a tsumani of physical or verbal abuse. People do not go insane because someone else's family tree is warped (who cares?), but they do inherit the emotional resonance that their own family tree passes down.

It is much less troubling, I suppose, for parents and patient alike to accept the idea of an insane world, rather than to accept the idea of insane family dynamics. The insane world view has much in common then with the diseased brain view of mental illness. Both deflect the situation in ways that don't point the finger at any one individual, thus making the situation palatable and guilt-free.

I said to a friend one time when my children were very young and they were all at their most challenging/difficult/wimpy (take your pick), "I like my own children but other people's children I can do without." She heartily agreed that the same applied to her. The brewing period for mental illness is the period of childhood where the family is being formed, imperfectly. Families understand each other on some level, but do not understand the way other families relate with each other.

Society is insane, but "mental illness" begins and ends at home. The "mental illness" usually manifests when the older child leaves his small world and steps out into the threatening larger one. Rather than the individual  directly confronting past hurts, psychosis feels like a "safe" way to express accusations, that if expressed honestly and directly, would trouble other family members.